I usually post my reviews of books, music, and film on my personal blog, but the film I watched last night and am about to review seemed a better fit here. For years, I have been actively working with students who are passionate about Global Issues, Social Justice, and student activism. Helping students raise their awareness about the issues we face as a citizens of one shared planet and helping them find ways to effectively spurn action is really the only reason I got into teaching. I am a firm believer that all content and skills no matter the class should have some connection to a better understanding of Global Issues. School should be a place where our curriculum culminates on making life on Earth better for as many people as we can. Forget getting kids ready for college, I want to get them ready to save our lives! We are very to close some pretty scary times, to waste time on anything else would be criminal. We need this generation and every generation after it to be aware, vocal, and active. If I sound panicked, it is because I am.
I was a bit apprehensive about watching The Age of Stupid. Someone had sent me the link on Twitter a while back, and the film has sat on my hard drive since. I’m not sure if it was the title or the lackluster trailer, but something about it made me feel like it wouldn’t be any good. Last night with my wife out of town, I decided to give it a try and man was I pleasantly surprised.
The blurb from IMDB reads:
This ambitious documentary/drama/animation hybrid stars Pete Postlethwaite as an archivist in the devastated world of the future, asking the question: “Why didn’t we stop climate change when we still had the chance?” He looks back on footage of real people around the world in the years leading up to 2015 before runaway climate change took place.
Wikipedia says
Amid news reports of the gathering effects of climate change and global civilisation teetering towards destruction, he alights on six stories of individuals whose lives in the early years of the 21st century seem to illustrate aspects of the impending catastrophe. These six stories take the form of interweaving documentary segments that report on the lives of real people in the present, and switch the film’s narrative form from fiction to fact. The people who feature are:
Al Duvernay, a resident of New Orleans who stayed behind and helped in the aftermath of hurricane Katrina. He reflects on what it feels like to have had all his possessions washed away in the flood, and also on his job in the oil industry and how valuable resources are being wasted.
Indian businessman Jehangir Wadia, who talks about the start-up of his low cost airline GoAir and his democratic vision of a world in which all people, rich and poor, are able to afford air travel.
Two Iraqi children, Jamila and Adnan, who fled with their family to Jordan during the Iraq War, who tell the story of their father’s death and of their desire to be reunited with the older brother they left behind.
Fernand Pareau, an 82-year-old man who works as a guide on the Mont Blanc glacier in France – he takes an English family on a tour of the glacier and explains how he has seen the ice recede massively in his lifetime. The guide is also shown taking action against expanding road infrastructure in his area.
Wind-farm developer, Piers Guy who talks about his efforts to bring sustainable energy to an English village, and how he is being blocked by people who profess a commitment to fighting global warming but do not want wind turbines destroying their views. His family takes action in reducing their carbon footprint and contemplate the effects of air travel.
Layefa Malemi, a Nigerian woman who struggles with poverty despite the wealth of oil in her country. She talks about her ambition to study medicine and the everyday impact of the exploitation of oil by Shell Nigeria on health, security and the environment in Nigeria.
These glimpses into the lives of a disparate group of people all affected by the oil industry are a perfect backdrop to the main message of the film. Which are: that it highlights the fundamental causes that have brought us to where we are as a species- A species that is rapidly destroying its own habitat. One of the most frustrating factors about working with young people who want to learn about global issues is that we rarely dig deep enough to truly understand the core causes that connect so many issues like climate change, poverty conflict etc…
We work on projects to educate students about recycling and green living, or maybe discuss the state of a world where most people live on a dollar a day, but at the end of the day most students, as least the ones I work with, will return to their world of blind consumerism that has been drilled into them since birth by the ever expanding global free market, because they are never asked to really look at the source of the problems. It is one thing to lead a recycling program at a school or help build schools in Africa, but no sustainable change, not the kind we need to save us from extinction, will come from such surface level actions without true understanding.
We need to help kids look deeply at why the world’s wealth is horded by a small number of its citizens, while so many people suffer. We cannot be afraid to examine concepts like colonialism, imperialism, and capitalism. We cannot expect a student to understand why Africa is “always so messed up,” without understanding the rape of the continent by European countries centuries ago. Student can never understand the root causes of terrorism and conflicts in the Middle East without having a basic understanding of imperialism and the implications of fossil fuels on the world’s military powerhouse’s need for it.
One site I recently found that does a great job of helping kids look beyond simple living green platitudes is Dropping Knowledge. Covering a range of ideas from gender equality to animal rights, the site does not shy away from asking questions that most teachers would avoid, and the best part is that student asks the questions themselves. If you really want a deep and robust Global Issues program I suggest you have your students take the time to ponder a few of them.
Back to the film. The Age of Stupid does a great job of getting to the source of many of our problems. White its focus is on the effects of climate change, there are a few animated segments that highlight the concepts I mentioned earlier. Cause of the perfect length and simplicity, I highly recommend you use them with students as discussion starters. This clip highlights how nearly all human conflicts have been a result of human beings’ need for resources, played perfectly over the backdrop of colonialism and imperialism, it subtly segues into the role of oil in current conflicts.
This clip could lead to great discussions about how the world’s imperialistic need for resources and control is not something we simply study in history, but that this lust for goods is the source of our problems today.
The second clip illustrates how our casual attitude toward consumerism stems from the impetus of the same capitalistic motives. The clip does not shy away from putting capitalism in the spotlight and questioning how we are expected to understand a system that is based on infinite growth using finite resources. That very question, alone, could lead to some intense discoveries for young people.
They are told everyday, everywhere they look that there is one system that epitomizes progress, and this system demands that they must consume to be successful. It must be our goal as Global Issues facilitators to not only change how they act by doing futile recycling drives, but how they think about their own roles as consumers and global citizens. We must allow young people to consider alternative economic systems and ways of life. Before I get a rash of comments telling me that Stalin and Mao didn’t work, and the free market system is the best we can do, let me say, “I get it.” I am not championing communism here. I am saying that we must have a completely new system. New ways of thinking. We cannot continue to believe that we will survive within a system that demands progress and growth as if we have infinite resources. We need today’s young people to help us, and they cannot if the do not understand the past and are blinded by the false hype of capitalism. It cannot be considered blasphemy to criticize and examine a system that is in crisis. A system that is literally leading us to extinction. Now is the time.
The Age of Stupid reminds us that we are headed for some dark times. It also points out the terrible suffering endured by many of the planet’s citizens so that we can live in the comfort and ease we have come to expect in the “developed” world. Nothing will change until young people are exposed to the underlying causes of our planet in collapse. This film is a great first step to getting them to think about these causes.
It was 8th grade and I remember you saying something that even today is stuck in my head. The system isn’t broken. It’s just the way it is. I have a drawing in my language arts notebook (i shall take a picture and upload soon to show you). it’s this diagram, like a web. and at the very bottom i have written down “it’s not broke, it’s designed this way”
If back then in that classroom, where I sat in a corner with Julia, you taught me this, and opened my eyes, look after about 3 years, i still have that notebook and i still am looking at that diagram.
Flip a few pages ahead in my book. i have a title saying “mankind is my business” i have a list of pro’s and cons to why i should be involved in taking care of mankind.
my pro’s say
– only people like us can afford it
– we have to help, or else no one will.
– we have to survive, no one gets left behind!
my cons say
– it’s not going to be appreciated if I help, no one cares
– it’s other organizations job to help people
– i’m trying to survive on my own, why should I help others?
at the bottom scribbled in the margin is says. is not helping going to bring me joy? what’s happens if I at least try? what’s wrong with trying? and today I am trying. I am trying.
flip ahead a few pages. i have a free writing entry about power. the quote is “power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely” I see it know. in the news, on my life. everywhere.
As I am typing this, it’s all coming back. As I flip through those dusty pages, they have a whole new meaning. You said “Nothing will change until young people are exposed to the underlying causes of our planet in collapse.” and you also say “Forget getting kids ready for college, I want to get them ready to save our lives!”
Let me tell you this. Your work as a teacher is paying off. I am one person out there, who is working on saving out lives. And it’s all because of you. Thank you very much.
Although I’m not going to dig out my old schoolbooks from the mountains of unpacked boxes, I will note that I, too, have that notebook and those notes. I still remember taking them, and only the other day I wrote ‘power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely’ on my world geography notes as another connection to government systems. I miss classes where we examined the reading material as a connection to real life and history (and thus its effect on modern and future eras) instead of as some untouchable realm; how did my middle school English class end up more advanced than my AP course?
What I have noticed now, after switching schools every year for the past few years, that many education systems are not open to discussing inflammatory issues. In my aforementioned world geography class, we could be currently discussing the governmental issues in the modern world and analyzing their past and future significance, but instead, we’re simply drilling definitions and modeling hypothetical situations. Surely students would learn more from the intrinsic capabilities of some issues to cause debate, conflict, even offense? I know I’d find my classes more interesting if we sometimes approached the modern world with a critical eye (instead of through rose-tinted glasses) and had an open and frank discussion instead of copying down vocabulary words.
My class defined communism, capitalism, consumerism, socialism… but we didn’t discuss them.
It seems such a shame to me that schooling, as one gets older, becomes less and less about deeper meaning and more and more about passing the tests. This is especially true about AP courses; I have been told for years that these courses are “more rigorous, more influenced by the less-than-obvious parts of subjects and situations” but, in reality, we’re simply compiling a large study guide for a test we will take, forget about, and move away from next year. Perhaps this is a fundamental issue with many courses: the test is more important. There is never time for musing, only facts and figures.
I agree that the world needs to address and talk about these things, which I admit are not easy to talk about. But how are we supposed to be able to talk about them if no one brings them up? If many teachers believe that they are readying students for the workplace and the so-called “real world”, then why don’t they breach the touchy subjects that the “real world” contains and we will have to face every single day?
It’s times like these where I find myself turning more and more to nonfiction to satisfy the need for information that schools graze over but don’t dig their teeth into. I have a pile of books to one side of my desk, but I never have chance to read them; I’m too busy writing definitions.
Wow! You guys. Such great comments; you humble me. The work goes both ways. I only helped a need for knowledge and an innate compassion that was already there. Julia, you ask a great question:
How did my middle school English class end up more advanced than my AP course?
I think it is because the prime narrative of formal education has become test scores, accountability and readiness for college first then the workplace. For all the mission statements of various schools, very few institutions are really enough to have deeper conversations about meaningful issues. You raise some great points about education systems are not open to discussing inflammatory issues.
Finally the following question has been the guiding light of my pedagogy from the start “how are we supposed to be able to talk about them if no one brings them up?”
I will share this post and your comment with many educators in the future. It is a perfect example of the frustration many teachers and I assume students have with the timidity of formal ed.
Thank you both.
Whenever I listen to the (US) newradio and then despair of nearly flat consumer spending or lower-than 3% GDP growth, I wonder why our economy needs to grow any faster than our population? Why do we need all those “new housing starts”?
I am looking forward to digging up this movie for my environmental science class. Sounds fascinating.
You are all spot on and it warms my heart to know that you are asking the questions! Keep asking the questions! As I am back in the classroom this year and currently discussing Terrorism it makes me think about really coming to an understanding of why people do the things they do. It’s not about knowing what the events are but understanding people. Same goes for Climate change, not that we don’t have the ability but lets try and understand the motives and habits. I have always been an advocate of questioning the status quo and asking for people to explain their decisions. Perhaps when I watch this movie it will give me some realistic ammo to spark the if we don’t discussions.
I am so excited about this new school I am working in and getting the opportunity to see what real dedication to making a difference is by an organization means but I still question the true habit, motivation and doing for the right reasons. Tricky one but my plan is to open this school and this be not what we do but who we are. I can only hope to have educators like you Jabiz and students like Leila and Julia! Proud of what you are doing and excited to see what is to come.
M Johnston
Hi, I’m Nicole and I’m in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. I really liked this post! The world is getting closer to scary times and we should be getting kids ready. I really enjoyed the way you put all that. Climate change is very important and I’m really glad you posted your review on this blog! We all do need a true understanding of climate change and other things that affect our lives. You have very strong opinions and I really appreciate that!. I enjoyed reading your blog and watching the videos. If you’d like to see my full comment check out my blog. http://kelleyfrancesedm310.blogspot.com/
First of all Nicole, thanks for reading and taking the time to comment. It is always humbling to know that people value your ideas and take the time to comment. I have strong opinions I guess, because i have two little girls and I want to make the world a better place then when I found it. No easy task, I know
But this is the field we have chosen. Thanks again for your commenting. Take some time to read some of the other comments as well. I think Julia raises some great points.
Pingback: | Intrepid Teacher
Pingback: The Age of Stupid – some resources « Escuela del Valle English Blog